Environmental common sense

Sometimes it seems that no matter how hard you work and how many changes and improvements you make, you still can’t get ahead. Members of the oil heating industry could be excused for feeling that way these days.

A combination of new technologies, new regulations along with increased diligence by contractors and oil delivery personnel have allowed the industry to make tremendous strides in reducing the number and seriousness of heating oil spills. But the cost of cleaning up the spills that do occur has gone up dramatically, so there has been little if any gain.

As Canadian Oil Heat Association chairman Robert Fortin remarked at the group’s annual meeting: “Remediation costs in the past 10 years have gone though the roof. What used to be 50 grand; now it’s multiplied by 10.”

As mentioned in the same article in the July/August issue of Plumbing & HVAC and repeated below, the bill for a residential spill cleanup near Orangeville, Ont. that was originally estimated at $170,000 eventually came in at $1.1 million. In the lawsuit that followed, the judge noted that a lack of oversight of the cleanup company, delays, the use of a company that was not local and charged travel time for employees and a number of other factors all contributed to the extremely high cost.

But the bottom line is that a “cost is no object” approach has become the norm when it comes to the environment. A more pragmatic approach is needed. We don’t want to go back to the days when oil spills were common, seldom reported and the homeowner would just live with the oil smell until eventually the earth regenerated itself. But at the same time, there needs to be some clear science on cleaning up oil spills as to how much really needs to be done to prevent long-term environmental damage and odors. Would cleaning up 95 percent of the oil be enough? Probably, unless it’s an exceptionally large spill. However, this is not really an option as current laws – Ontario’s Environmental Protection Act, for example – require that the site of a spill be restored to pre-spill conditions.

Better oversight of the companies that clean up the spills is a must, as the judge noted. If the cleanup contractor knows that the insurance company is going to pay the bill no matter how high it goes, then the bill will likely be very high indeed.

The industry, in co-operation with government and the insurance industry, needs to develop standardized cleanup procedures and some form of certification for the companies that do remediation work.

The current situation evolved in large part because nobody really took a leadership role on spill cleanups. If we are to bring some common sense to this issue, we need an industry driven solution based on cost effective and proven practices.

Navien 2014/03/7-14
COHA sets priorities
Spills, insurance dominate discussion at oil heating conference...Full Story
TSSA appoints ombudsman
In May the Technical Standards and Safety Authority of Ontario (TSSA) appointed an ombudsman to help contractors in disputes, something the industry has long sought...Full Story
Calgary trade show to highlight hydronics
The CIPHEX West trade show will return to Calgary Nov. 5-6 with an impressive seminar schedule....Full Story
Habitat Ride raises $12,700
Motorcycle riding members of the industry and friends met July 12 on a nearly perfect day in Southern Ontario in a fund raising ride for Habitat for Humanity....Full Story
Two-year implementation plan announced for new Ont. sprinkler and fire protection trade
Ontario will allow a two-year transition phase for the new compulsory sprinkler and fire protection trade....Full Story
Protection from power surges, brownouts and short cycles in today’s HVAC/R equipment with computerized controls is just as important as it is with computers....more

The PACE Model 1112 portable roll groover from Mag Tool uses just three top rollers and three bottom rollers to produce specification quality grooves in pipe from one-inch through 12” diameter Schedule 40....more

The Teletube Urinal Auger from General Pipe Cleaners features a specially designed 48-inch spring designed with the toughness and flexibility to negotiate tight urinal bends, allowing it to also clear stoppages beyond the urinal....more

Mechanical Contractor’s Association of Canada 73rd National Conference
SEPT. 24-27, 2014

Delta St. John’s Hotel, St. John’s, Nfld. Call (613) 232-0492 or visit www.mcac.ca

CIPHEX West Trade Show and Conference
NOV. 5-6, 2014

BMO Centre, Stampede Park, Calgary. Contact Elizabeth McCullough at 1-800-639-2474 or visit www.ciphexwest.ca

Construct Canada
DEC. 3-5, 2014
Metro Toronto Conventio Centre, South Building, Toronto. Visit www.constructcanada.com or call (416) 512-3815


  • Oil heat industry struggles with spill cleanup costs
  • Ontario adopts two-year phase-in for sprinkler trade
  • TSSA appoints ombudman to hear contractor concerns
  • Solids corpoparate structure boost success rate
July 2014
©2014 Newcom Business Media Inc.